Concerns mount as independent panel investigating HPD’s suspended cases meet for 1st time

Concerns are escalating over the composition of the panel tasked with investigating the Houston Police Department’s decision not to investigate over 260,000 cases, as announced by HPD Chief Troy Finner last month due to staffing shortages. Mayor John Whitmire initiated calls for an independent review after this revelation, but doubts have been raised about the panel’s independence and representation.

Attorney Randall Kallinen and other community activists have voiced apprehensions regarding the panel’s makeup, claiming it lacks true independence and representation from organizations such as the League of United Latin American Citizens (LULAC) or the NAACP. Kallinen criticized the selection process, alleging that the panel consists mainly of individuals associated with the mayor or influenced by their positions.

The panel, chaired by former state lawmaker and city council member Ellen Cohen, includes Texas Ranger Jeff Owles, Reverend Leon Preston, city of Houston deputy inspector general Christina Nowak, and city attorney Arturo Michel. However, Kallinen and others fear potential biases due to their close ties to HPD.

Despite attempts to address these concerns, including raising them directly with Mayor Whitmire, who left the meeting before they could be aired, doubts persist. Professor Kimberly Dodson from the University of Houston-Clear Lake emphasized the panel’s limited size, connections, and lack of subpoena power, suggesting it may not be sufficiently equipped to conduct an effective investigation.

While Mayor Whitmire has defended the panel’s credibility and assured transparency, Kallinen remains dissatisfied with its composition and urges ongoing transparency throughout the investigation. Furthermore, activists are encouraging crime victims affected by HPD’s inaction to come forward, emphasizing the need for accountability and addressing cases with expired statute of limitations.

The demand for Chief Troy Finner’s recusal from the investigation has gained traction, with both community activists and the police union advocating for his removal during this process. However, HPD has yet to comment on this matter.

The panel’s inaugural meeting is scheduled for Wednesday, where it is expected to begin its review of the HPD’s handling of the overlooked cases.