Texas Ranger on independent panel reviewing HPD puts impartiality into question, expert says

In Houston, Texas, city leaders have pledged transparency regarding the Houston Police Department’s handling of over a quarter-million suspended incident reports, a promise reiterated by Chief Troy Finner and Mayor John Whitmire at a March 7 press conference.

To uphold accuracy and transparency for victims and the public, Mayor Whitmire announced the formation of an independent panel comprising five members. These individuals include former councilwoman and state Rep. Ellen Cohen, current Texas Ranger Jeff Owles, city attorney Arturo Michel, Houston deputy inspector general Christina Nowak, and reverend and Harris County Sheriff’s Chaplain Leon Preston.

Despite the commitment to transparency, concerns arose when it was revealed that panel members were advised against speaking to journalists. Eyewitness News sought clarification from the panel members, particularly regarding their ability to remain impartial while scrutinizing the work of their city colleagues.

Efforts to reach Texas Ranger Owles were unsuccessful, while Reverend Preston referred to a statement that was not received. The mayor’s office indicated that Nowak and Michel were instructed not to engage with journalists.

Of the panel members, only Ellen Cohen has spoken publicly, expressing confidence in the panel’s composition and readiness to commence its duties.

Kimberly Dodson, a criminology professor at the University of Houston-Clear Lake, expressed reservations about the panel’s size and potential biases. Drawing from her experience on independent review panels outside of Texas, Dodson emphasized the importance of diversity and inclusivity in such committees.

Dodson raised concerns about the presence of a current law enforcement member on the panel, noting potential conflicts of interest. She also questioned the inclusion of the city attorney, citing a potential conflict due to their duty to protect the city’s interests.

Furthermore, Dodson highlighted the limitations faced by the panel, particularly its inability to subpoena individuals or conduct computer audits. Without these powers, she suggested the panel may encounter challenges in gathering necessary information.

In response to these concerns, a spokesperson for Mayor Whitmire’s office reiterated that the panel’s focus is not on criminal investigation but rather on reviewing HPD’s work and outcomes. The spokesperson emphasized the credibility and diverse backgrounds of the panel members, affirming their responsibility to provide answers and accountability to the public.